Skip to main content
AFS Financial Group

The 4% Rule vs. the 8% Rule: What’s the Right Withdrawal Rate for You?

Phil’s Tax Hacks · July 16, 2026

Here’s some of what we discuss in this episode:

⚖️ Rate Debate: Comparing two very different approaches

📉 Market Reality: Withdrawals become harder during downturns

📏 Rule Limits: Simple guidelines cannot replace strategy

🤝 Advisor Guidance: Make honest changes as life evolves

Today’s Hack

Dave Ramsey has built one of the most recognized brands in personal finance. Millions of people have followed his advice out of debt and into savings. But when it comes to how much you should pull from your retirement accounts each year, Ramsey takes a position that some financial professionals find hard to get behind. Today, we break it down: what Dave says, what the research says, and what Phil thinks.

Go Inside the Episode:

0:00 – Intro

0:47 – Technology Frustrations

2:51 – 4% vs. 8%

4:18 – The 4% Rule and Its Limitations

6:18 – Challenges of Maintaining Rates

8:52 – Individualized Financial Planning

12:39 – Determining Your Withdrawal Rate

14:31 – AI Bubble Coming?

17:21 – Revisiting Your Plan

18:47 – Reach Out to Phil

Ramsey’s 8% Retirement Rule Sounds Nuts At First

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/ramsey-8-retirement-rule-sounds-170209842.html

The 4% Rule May Be Costing Retirees Money, Morningstar Says

https://www.fa-mag.com/news/the-4–rule-may-be-costing-retirees-money–morningstar-says-87521.html

 

If you have any questions about what we discussed in this episode, reach out and we’ll be happy to set up a time to talk.

Get your copy of The Tax-Smart Retiree: https://www.thetaxsmartretireebook.com/welcome

You’ve worked hard for your money. We help make your money work hard for you.

Want help to plan your Tax-Smart Retirement™? Click below to schedule a call.

Yes, Let’s Talk

You are leaving the AFS Financial Group website and will be redirected to a third-party website. AFS Financial Group does not control or maintain that website and is not responsible for its content, availability, security, or privacy practices. The link does not constitute an endorsement of all information, products, or services offered on the third-party website. Please review the third party’s terms of use and privacy policy.